Mūsā al-Ḥabashī, Dayr Mār

formerly Syr. Orth., now Syr. Catholic

Mūsā al-Ḥabashī, Dayr Mār

* So I need to output:
formerly Syr. Orth., now Syr. Catholic by Erica Cruikshank Dodd

Mūsā al-Ḥabashī, Dayr Mār [formerly Syr. Orth., now Syr. Catholic]

  • {content} *

Body

Monastery of Moses the Ethiopian, perched on top of a steep, rocky promontory south of Nabk.

埃塞俄比亚的摩西修道院 (Monastery of Moses the Ethiopian),高踞于纳布克 (Nabk) 以南一处陡峭的岩石岬角之上。

The Monastery of Moses the Ethiopian is perched on top of a steep, rocky promontory that juts out of a deep gully between two cliffs in the high region south of Nabk. The earliest historical reference to the monastery is in a hand-written note beside a text of John Chrysostom on the Gospel of Matthew, in a 6th-cent. ms. preserved in the British Library. A second note in the same ms. states that this volume was ‘the property of the convent of Mushe, on the hill called “the Great Head,” east of Natpha, in the province of Damascus’. The subsequent history of the monastery is closely documented by numerous inscriptions within the church, and by mss. that once belonged to its flourishing scriptorium. Until the end of the 14th cent. it was the seat of a bishopric that later fell under the jurisdiction of Ḥama and Mardin , and then under the bishopric of Jerusalem and Damascus (Kaufhold).

埃塞俄比亚人摩西修道院 (Monastery of Moses the Ethiopian) 坐落于纳布克 (Nabk) 以南高地区域两座悬崖之间深沟突出的陡峭岩石岬角之巅。关于该修道院最早的历史记载见于大英图书馆 (British Library) 珍藏的一份 6 世纪手稿 (6th-cent. ms.) 中,即金口约翰 (John Chrysostom) 关于《马太福音》(Gospel of Matthew) 的文本旁的一份手写笔记。同一份手稿 (ms.) 中的第二份笔记指出,该卷书是“穆谢 (Mushe) 修道院的财产,位于大马士革 (Damascus) 省纳特法 (Natpha) 以东名为‘大头’ (the Great Head) 的山丘上”。该修道院的后续历史由教堂内的众多铭文以及曾属于其繁荣抄写室 (scriptorium) 的手稿 (mss.) 得到了详细记录。直到 14 世纪 (14th cent.) 末,它一直是一个主教区 (bishopric) 的所在地,后来归于哈马 (Ḥama) 和马尔丁 (Mardin) 的管辖之下,随后又归于耶路撒冷 (Jerusalem) 和大马士革 (Damascus) 主教区 (bishopric) 的管辖 (Kaufhold)。

The monastery prospered well into the 18th cent. and was recorded by both Burton and Moritz late in the 19th cent., but some time thereafter was totally abandoned and fell into ruin. The fortress-like building was approached through a small door on the top floor, from where it was built four stories down; but when discovered again in 1981, the lower floors had all caved in and the upper terrace had only one room that sheltered sheep. At that time the chapel was still preserved, its walls decorated with falling, painted stucco but the roof and the ciborium were gone, burned for firewood. A young Jesuit, Father Paolo dall’Oglio, an Orientalist by training, visited the site and decided to restore the monastery to its former state. With great care to reproduce its original plan and accoutrements, and with the help of local teams of Christian volunteers from Syria and Iraq, with experts in the Department of Antiquities in Damascus, and the Istituto del Restauro in Rome, Father Paolo cleared the lower rooms and rebuilt the upper stories and the chapel. In subsequent years he dug a well, added outlying buildings, and established a new order for the monastery. He now presides over a small group of monks, nuns, and novitiates in a religious center dedicated to serving the surrounding community of Christians and Muslims and to promoting a dialogue between them. The monastery receives daily a great number of visitors, both Christian and Muslim.

该修道院繁荣直至 18 世纪 (18th cent.),19 世纪 (19th cent.) 后期由伯顿 (Burton) 和莫里茨 (Moritz) 均有记载,但此后某段时间被完全废弃并沦为废墟。这座堡垒式建筑通过顶层的一扇小门进入,从那里向下建有四层;但在 1981 年再次被发现时,下层楼层均已坍塌,上层露台仅剩一间牧羊的房间。当时小教堂尚存,墙壁装饰着剥落的彩绘灰泥,但屋顶和华盖 (ciborium) 已不见踪影,被当作柴火烧掉了。一位年轻的耶稣会士 (Jesuit),受过东方学家 (Orientalist) 训练的保罗·达尔奥廖神父 (Father Paolo dall’Oglio),参观了该遗址并决定将修道院恢复至昔日的状态。怀着极大的细心以重现其原始规划和装备,并在来自叙利亚 (Syria) 和伊拉克 (Iraq) 的当地基督教志愿者团队、大马士革文物局 (Department of Antiquities in Damascus) 的专家以及罗马修复研究所 (Istituto del Restauro) 的帮助下,保罗神父清理了下层房间,重建了上层楼层和小教堂。在随后的几年里,他挖了一口井,增加了外围建筑,并为修道院建立了一个新修会 (order)。他现在主持着一个由修士、修女和初学修士组成的小团体,这是一个宗教中心,致力于服务周围的基督徒和穆斯林社区,并促进他们之间的对话。修道院每天接待大量访客,包括基督徒和穆斯林。

For as long as the inhabitants of Nabk can remember, the monastery has been known as Mār Mūsā al-Ḥabashī (St. Moses the Ethiopian), but, according to the inscriptions and to the mss., it was originally dedicated to Mār Mūsā the Prophet (St. Moses the Prophet). The earliest reference to Moses the Ethiopian comes from the 17th cent. It is possible that this saint became associated with the monastery on the arrival of a number of Abyssinian monks in the 15th cent. (Cruikshank Dodd). These monks from Mar Girgios al-Ḥabash, in Ehden, and Mar Yaʿqub al-Ḥabash in Bsharre, were evicted from the Qadisha valley by the Maronites in 1488. In this case the change of name from Mār Mūsā, to Mār Mūsā al-Ḥabash (of the Ethiopians), to Mār Mūsā al-Ḥabashi (the Ethiopian) might have come about naturally in the process of time. A hand encased in a silver casket purporting to be the hand of Mar Moses the Ethiopian is inscribed as a donation to the monastery by Bp. Eliya in 1817 and is now preserved in the Church of the Virgin, in Nabk. The Syr. Orth. Christians of Nabk celebrate the feast of Moses the Ethiopian on 28 Aug. In the Greek Church his feast day is 18 June.

据纳布克 (Nabk) 居民的记忆所能追溯,该修道院一直被称为圣摩西·哈巴希 (Mār Mūsā al-Ḥabashī)(圣摩西·埃塞俄比亚人),但根据铭文和手稿 (mss.),它最初是奉献给圣摩西先知 (Mār Mūsā the Prophet)(圣摩西先知)的。关于埃塞俄比亚人摩西的最早记载来自 17 世纪 (17th cent.)。这位圣人可能与修道院的关联始于 15 世纪 (15th cent.) 一批阿比西尼亚 (Abyssinian) 修士的到来 (Cruikshank Dodd)。这些来自埃赫登 (Ehden) 的圣吉尔吉斯·哈巴什 (Mar Girgios al-Ḥabash) 和卜舍里 (Bsharre) 的圣雅各布·哈巴什 (Mar Yaʿqub al-Ḥabash) 的修士,于 1488 年被马龙派 (Maronites) 从卡迪沙河谷 (Qadisha valley) 驱逐。在这种情况下,名称从圣摩西 (Mār Mūsā),到圣摩西·哈巴什 (Mār Mūsā al-Ḥabash)(埃塞俄比亚人的),再到圣摩西·哈巴希 (Mār Mūsā al-Ḥabashi)(埃塞俄比亚人),可能是随着时间的推移自然发生的。一只装在银盒子里的手,据称是圣摩西·哈巴希 (Mar Moses the Ethiopian) 的手,上面刻有 1817 年伊利亚 (Eliya) 主教 (Bp.) 捐赠给修道院的铭文,现保存在纳布克 (Nabk) 的圣母教堂 (Church of the Virgin)。纳布克 (Nabk) 的叙利亚正教 (Syr. Orth.) 基督徒在 8 月 28 日 (28 Aug.) 庆祝埃塞俄比亚人摩西的纪念日。在希腊教会 (Greek Church) 中,他的纪念日是 6 月 18 日 (18 June)。

The various stages in the monastery’s long history are recorded in inscriptions. Those carved in the building stones indicate that the church was rebuilt and renovated in A.H. 504 (= AD 1058/1059). Subsequently, it was enlarged and turned into a fortress in the 15th cent. and restored again in the 16th. Inscriptions painted on the wall paintings identify the figures and scenes. Earlier layers of painting are inscribed in Greek, whereas the top layer for the most part uses Syriac. There are also dedications and memorials written on the paintings themselves by various visitors to the monastery, in Syriac and in Arabic, that contribute to the history of the monastery (Tweir, Haddad, Muwazzin, ter Haar Romeny et al.).

修道院漫长历史中的各个阶段均记录于铭文之中。刻在建筑石材上的铭文表明,该教堂于伊斯兰历 (A.H.) 504 年(= 公元 (AD) 1058/1059 年)重建并修缮。随后,它在 15 世纪被扩建并改为堡垒,并于 16 世纪再次修复。壁画上的铭文标识了人物与场景。较早的绘画层以希腊文题写,而最上层大部分使用叙利亚文。此外,还有修道院的各种访客用叙利亚文和阿拉伯文直接写在画作上的奉献题记与纪念文字,这些内容有助于了解修道院的历史 (Tweir, Haddad, Muwazzin, ter Haar Romeny et al.)。

With this long and fascinating history, the chapel in Mār Mūsā al-Ḥabashī also preserves until today the most extensive series of paintings to have come down to us from the whole of the Levant (Cruikshank Dodd, Dall’Oglio, Westphalen, Immerzeel). The chapel is unique in that it shows a well-documented, coherent series of paintings from more than one period, paintings that are indispensable for the study of medieval Christian art.

拥有如此悠久而迷人的历史,马尔·穆萨·哈巴希 (Mār Mūsā al-Ḥabashī) 的礼拜堂至今仍保存着整个黎凡特 (Levant) 地区流传下来的规模最大的绘画系列 (Cruikshank Dodd, Dall’Oglio, Westphalen, Immerzeel)。该礼拜堂的独特之处在于,它展示了一系列记录详尽、连贯的绘画,来自不止一个时期,这些绘画对于中世纪基督教艺术的研究不可或缺。

There are three (or three and a half) principal layers of painting, applied at three different periods (Westphalen). The first, or earliest layer of paintings (layer 1), can be dated to the 11th cent. ca. 1060, soon after the first renovations to the church, to which more wall paintings were added a few years later (1a), at some time before 1095. Another layer (2) is dated by an inscription on the Baptismal scene to 1095. The latest series (3) is the most extensive and best preserved. The date of the third layer is recorded in an inscription over a painting of the Evangelist Matthew, and it may be read as either 1192 (assuming that the Seleucid calendar is followed), or 1208/9 (if it is taken as a Hijra year), a distinction which is, unfortunately, not clear in the original.

共有三层(或三层半)主要的绘画层,绘制于三个不同的时期(威斯特法伦 (Westphalen))。第一层,即最早的绘画层(第 1 层),可断代为 11 世纪,约 1060 年,即在教堂首次修缮后不久;几年后(1a 层)又增添了更多壁画,时间在 1095 年之前的某个时候。另一层(第 2 层)根据洗礼场景上的一处铭文断代为 1095 年。最新的一组(第 3 层)规模最为宏大且保存最为完好。第三层的日期记录在福音书作者马太 (Matthew) 画像上方的一处铭文中,该日期既可读作 1192 年(假设遵循塞琉古历 (Seleucid calendar)),也可读作 1208/9 年(若视为希吉拉历 (Hijra year) 年份),遗憾的是,原文中这一区分并不明确。

The interior of the chapel was elaborately painted when it was first restored in 1058/9. Beneath the more recent remains of the third layer, there is a bust of Christ on the triumphal arch with what appear to be archangels at either side. Above these figures there may have been painted the Forty Martyrs of Sebaste (Immerzeel). An Annunciation was placed on either side of the window. The riding saints, Theodore and George, appear opposite each other on the spandrels of the arches in the nave, where also the remains of a second pair may be traced from this early date. Still in the nave, on the southern spandrel nearest to the apse is the Ascension of Elijah in his Chariot. In the southern aisle, west end, an early representation of the Presentation in the Temple (?) is balanced by a group of apostles, probably the Pentecost, at the west end of the northern aisle. In the southern aisle, an image of Samson and the Lion is painted high above the western arch. At the east end, there may have been an early Baptism in the northern aisle and an early Myrophores (Three Women at the Tomb) in the southern aisle. The columns and the soffits of the arches are decorated with standing saints and martyrs, both male and female most of whom were added shortly after this first layer (period 1a).

这座小教堂的内部在 1058/9 年首次修复时进行了精心绘制。在较晚的第三层残留物之下,凯旋拱门上有一尊基督 (Christ) 的半身像,两侧似乎是大天使。在这些人物上方,可能曾绘制过塞巴斯蒂 (Sebaste) 的四十殉道者 (Forty Martyrs of Sebaste)(伊默泽尔 (Immerzeel))。窗户两侧各绘有一幅圣母领报 (Annunciation)。骑乘的圣徒,狄奥多尔 (Theodore) 和乔治 (George),相对出现在中殿拱门的拱肩上,在此处也可追溯到这一早期日期的第二对人物的残留痕迹。仍在中殿,靠近后殿的南侧拱肩上是乘战车升天的以利亚 (Elijah)。在南侧廊西端,一幅早期的献主于圣殿 (Presentation in the Temple) (?) 图像,与北侧廊西端的一组使徒(可能是五旬节 (Pentecost))相呼应。在南侧廊,一幅参孙 (Samson) 与狮子的图像绘制在西拱门上方高处。在东端,北侧廊可能曾有一幅早期的洗礼 (Baptism) 图,南侧廊则有一幅早期的携香膏者 (Myrophores)(墓前三妇女)图。柱子和拱门的拱腹装饰着站立的圣徒和殉道者,男女皆有,其中大多数是在这第一层之后不久添加的(1a 期 (period 1a))。

Layer 2 (1095) comprises a large Baptism, painted over the earlier Baptism at the eastern end of the northern aisle, and a renewed Myrophores painted over the earlier one in the southern aisle. A stylite Saint ( Shemʿun the Stylite ?) stands beside the Baptism. At the western end of the southern aisle is a renewed Presentation in the Temple.

第二层(1095 年)包含一幅大型洗礼图 (Baptism),绘制于北侧廊东端早期的洗礼图之上,以及一幅重绘的持香女 (Myrophores) 图,覆盖于南侧廊早期的图像之上。一位柱头圣人(舍姆恩柱头圣人 (Shemʿun the Stylite)?)立于洗礼图旁。南侧廊西端是一幅重绘的献主图 (Presentation in the Temple)。

Most of the extant paintings belong to layer three, the last layer of paint, 1192 or 1208/9. They present the most coherent series of paintings to have come down to us in the Syriac churches. The triumphal arch, high up under the eaves, is decorated with Christ Emmanuel and an Annunciation, below which is the Christ Pantocrator between the figures of twelve standing apostles that spill into the nave. In the apse was a Deesis (now largely destroyed) with the Christ on a throne surrounded by the four beasts of the Apocalypse. Below them, in the bema, the standing Virgin Blachernitissa between standing Church Fathers: Cyril of Alexandria , Basil , Athanasius , and John Chrysostom , on her right; and Ignatius , James, and two others (destroyed) on her left. On the iconastasis there are painted the five wise and five foolish virgins. Four large riding horsemen, George and Theodore, Bacchos and Sergios charge down the nave, above the arches, towards the apse. The remains of two other riding saints are visible nearer the apse, making six in all. Four evangelists writing their gospels fill the spandrels. On the western wall is a great Last Judgment above which is the Traditio clavium and the Traditio Legis, of which only the lower part of Peter and Paul remain. Below them the remaining ten Apostles are seated on either side of a Hetoimasia between Adam and Eve. On the one side, below the apostles, are the three patriarchs, Abraham, Isaac and Jacob, together with Mary, holding bunches of souls in their laps. Beneath them are the saints, martyrs and holy men ascending from their tombs to heaven at the blast of trumpeting angels. On the other side of the Hetoimasia stand heretical bishops and various groups of enemies of the orthodox churches, along with Satan seated among souls drowning in the waters of the Styx, a devil holding down the scales, and below them are naked women symbolizing the seven sins. The Last Judgment spills over onto the walls of the nave.

现存的大部分绘画属于第三层,即最后一层颜料层,年代为 1192 年或 1208/9 年。它们构成了流传至今的叙利亚教会 (Syriac churches) 中最连贯的一系列绘画。位于屋檐下方高处的凯旋拱门装饰有基督以马内利 (Christ Emmanuel) 和天使报喜 (Annunciation),其下方是基督全能者 (Christ Pantocrator),位于十二位站立使徒的形象之间,这些使徒延伸进入中殿。后殿中曾有一幅代祷图 (Deesis)(现已大部分损毁),描绘基督坐在宝座上,周围环绕着启示录 (Apocalypse) 的四活物。在它们下方,位于拜马坛 (bema) 处,站立着布拉赫内圣母 (Virgin Blachernitissa),介于站立的教会圣师 (Church Fathers) 之间:她的右侧是亚历山大的西里尔 (Cyril of Alexandria)、巴西尔 (Basil)、阿塔纳修斯 (Athanasius) 和约翰·克里索斯托 (John Chrysostom);左侧是伊格纳修斯 (Ignatius)、雅各 (James) 以及另外两位(已损毁)。圣像屏 (iconastasis) 上绘有五位聪明童女和五位愚拙童女。四位大型骑马武士,乔治 (George) 和狄奥多雷 (Theodore)、巴科斯 (Bacchos) 和塞尔吉奥斯 (Sergios),越过拱门上方,沿着中殿冲向後殿。靠近后殿处可见另外两位骑马圣徒的残迹,共计六位。四位福音书作者书写福音书的形象填满了拱肩。西墙上是一幅巨大的最后审判 (Last Judgment),其上方是《钥匙交付》(Traditio clavium) 和《律法交付》(Traditio Legis),其中仅存彼得 (Peter) 和保罗 (Paul) 的下半部分。在他们下方,其余十位使徒坐在预备宝座 (Hetoimasia) 的两侧,介于亚当 (Adam) 和夏娃 (Eve) 之间。在一侧,使徒下方是三位族长,亚伯拉罕 (Abraham)、以撒 (Isaac) 和雅各 (Jacob),连同玛利亚 (Mary),怀中抱着成群的灵魂。在他们下方是圣徒、殉道者和圣人,随着天使吹号的声音从坟墓中升向天堂。在预备宝座 (Hetoimasia) 的另一侧,站立着异端主教和各种正统教会 (orthodox churches) 的敌人,还有撒但 (Satan) 坐在淹没在冥河 (Styx) 水中的灵魂之间,一个魔鬼按住天平,他们下方是象征七宗罪的裸体女性。最后审判 (Last Judgment) 的画面延伸到了中殿的墙壁上。

Among these impressive scenes, the walls and the piers in Mār Mūsā are painted with numerous figures of standing saints and martyrs, including John the Baptist and Saba, Euthymios and Anthony (?). The soffits of the arches are reserved for female saints, among them: Anastasia, Catherine, Barbara, Elizabeth, and Julia (Juliana).

在这些令人印象深刻的场景中,马尔·穆萨 (Mār Mūsā) 的墙壁和墩柱上绘有许多站立的圣人和殉道者形象,包括施洗者约翰 (John the Baptist) 和萨巴 (Saba)、欧提米奥斯 (Euthymios) 和安东尼 (Anthony) (?)。拱券的拱腹专用于绘制女圣人,其中包括:阿纳斯塔西娅 (Anastasia)、凯瑟琳 (Catherine)、芭芭拉 (Barbara)、伊丽莎白 (Elizabeth) 和朱莉娅 (Julia/Juliana)。

These paintings are evidence of a continuing tradition of Christian painting in lands dominated by Muslim rulers. In their iconography, they kept alive the painterly tradition of the Early Christian Church and also followed closely Byzantine innovations from Constantinople. In the 12th cent., some iconographic elements were imported from Crusader Jerusalem . In their style, each of the layers of paint demonstrate a stylistic tradition in East Christian art that was aware of and sensitive to regional developments in Lebanon, Cyprus, Egypt, Iraq and Cappadocia. The painters were local Syrians who were also influenced by contemporary Islamic art in the region. On the whole, the paintings of Mār Mūsā al-Ḥabashī remain the richest illustration of East Christian art preserved until today.

这些绘画见证了在穆斯林 (Muslim) 统治者主导的地区中基督教绘画持续存在的传统。在图像志方面,它们延续了早期基督教会 (Early Christian Church) 的绘画传统,并密切追随来自君士坦丁堡 (Constantinople) 的拜占庭 (Byzantine) 创新。在 12 世纪 (12th cent.),一些图像志元素引入自十字军耶路撒冷 (Crusader Jerusalem)。在风格上,每一层颜料都体现了东方基督教艺术 (East Christian art) 中的一种风格传统,该传统知晓并敏感于黎巴嫩 (Lebanon)、塞浦路斯 (Cyprus)、埃及 (Egypt)、伊拉克 (Iraq) 和卡帕多西亚 (Cappadocia) 的区域发展。画师们是当地叙利亚人 (Syrians),同时也受到该地区当代伊斯兰 (Islamic) 艺术的影响。总体而言,马尔·穆萨·哈巴希 (Mār Mūsā al-Ḥabashī) 的绘画仍然是保存至今的东方基督教艺术 (East Christian art) 最丰富的例证。

See Fig. 85c, 86, 87, and 88c.

参见图 85c、86、87 和 88c。

References

Secondary Sources
  • A. Badwi, ‘The wall paintings of Mount Lebanon’, in Documentation and Conservation of Art in Syria. Papers of the Workshop held at Damascus University, 16–19 September, 1996 (2000), 61–8.
  • E. Cruikshank Dodd, The frescoes of Mar Musa al-Habashi. A study in medieval painting in Syria (Studies and Texts 139; 2001).
  • eadem, Medieval Painting in the Lebanon (2004).
  • P. Dall’Oglio et al., Il restauro del monastero di San Mosè l’Abassino, Nebek, Siria (1998).
  • J. Folda, The art of the crusaders in the Holy Land, 1098–1187 (1995).
  • , Crusader Art in the Holy Land. From the Third Crusade to the Fall of Acre (2005).
  • B. ter Haar Romeny et al., ‘The wall paintings and inscriptions of Deir Mar Musa al-Habashi’, ECA 4 (2007), 95–188.
  • N. Hélou, ‘L’icône bilaterale de la Vierge de Kaftoun au Liban: Une œuvre d’art syro-byzantin à l’époque des Croisés’, Chronos. Revue d’Histoire de l’Université de Balamand 7 (2003), 101–30.
  • eadem, ‘À propos d’une école syro-libanaise d’icônes au XIIIe siècle’, ECA 3 (2006), 53–72.
  • L.-A. Hunt, ‘Christian art in Greater Syria and Egypt: A triptych of the Ascension with Military Saints reattributed’, Al-Masāq 12 (2000), 1–36.
  • eadem, ‘A Woman’s Prayer to St. Sergios in Latin Syria. Interpreting a thirteenth-century icon at Mount Sinai’, Byzantine and Modern Greek Studies 15 (1991) 96–145. (repr. in Byzantium, Eastern Christendom and Islam. Art at the crossroads of the medieval Mediterranean, vol. 2 [2000], 78–126)
  • M. Immerzeel, ‘Le saint cavalier de Deir Saydet Hamatour’, Tempora. Annales d’histoire et d’archéologie 14–15 (2003–2004), 175–85.
  • ‘Medieval wall paintings in Lebanon: Donors and artists’, Chronos. Revue d’Histoire de l’Université de Balamand 10 (2004), 7–47.
  • , ‘The wall paintings in the Church of Mar Elian at Homs: A ‘restoration project’ of a nineteenth-century Palestinian master’, ECA 2 (2005), 149–65.
  • , ‘Monasteries and Churches of the Qalamun (Syria): Art and pilgrimage in the Middle Ages’, JCSSS 7 (2007), 74–98.
  • , ‘The Monastery of Our Lady of Saydnaya and its icon’, ECA 4 (2007), 13–26.
  • , Identity Puzzles. Medieval Christian art in Syria and Lebanon (OLA 184; 2009).
  • K. Innemée and M. Immerzeel, ‘The Chapel of the Prophet Elijah near Maʿarrat Saydnaya (Syria) and its mural paintings,’ Al-Masāq 12 (2000), 69–97.
  • H. Kaufhold, ‘Notizen über das Moseskloster bei Nabk und das Julianskloster bei Qaryatain in Syrien’, OC 79 (1995), 48–119.
  • J. Lassus, Sanctuaires chrétiens de Syrie (1947), 299–301, fig. 109.
  • J. Leroy, Les manuscrits syriaques à peintures conservés dans les bibliothèques d’Europe et d’Orient. Contribution à l’étude de l’iconographie des églises de langue syriaque (Institut français d’archéologie de Beyrouth. Bibliothèque archéologique et historique 77; 1964).
  • ‘La renaissance de l’église syriaque au XIIe–XIIIe siècles’, in Cahiers de civilisation médiévale 14 (1971), 131–48, 239–255.
  • , ‘Découvertes de peintures chrétiennes en Syrie’, Annales archéologiques arabes syriennes 25 (1975), 95–113.
  • M. Mundell, ‘Monophysite Church decoration’, in Iconoclasm. Papers given at the ninth Spring Symposium of Byzantine Studies, ed. A. Bryer and J. Herrin (1977), 59–74.
  • J. Nasrallah, ‘Le couvent de Saint Moîse l’Ethiopien dans le Djebel Kalamoun (Syrie)’, in Étape. Revue de la France Libre (1941).
  • , ‘La peinture monumentale des patriarchats Melkites’, in Icônes Melkites, Exposition organisée par le Musée Nicolas Sursock, 16 mai – 15 juin, 1969 (1969), 67–98.
  • L. Nordiguian, ‘Une chapelle peinte à Kfar Chlaïmane dans le haut-pays de Batroun’, MUSJ 54 (1995–6), 97–116.
  • , ‘La chapelle peinte de Saydet Hamatour dans le Koura’, Chronos. Revue d’Histoire de l’Université de Balamand 1 (1998), 67–89.
  • , ‘Note sur deux fragments de peinture à Saydet Kharayeb de Kfar Helda’, Tempora. Annales d’histoire et d’archéologie 14–15 (2003–2004), 187–92.
  • , ‘Une vision de Saint Eustathe au Liban’, Tempora. Annales d’histoire et d’archéologie 16–17 (2005–6), 163–9.
  • L. Nordiguian and J.-C. Voisin, Châteaux et églises du moyen âge au Liban (1999).
  • Y. Sader, Peintures murales dans les églises médiévales du Liban (1987).
  • , Painted churches and rock-cut chapels of Lebanon (1997).
  • A. Schmidt and S. Westphalen (ed.), Christliche Wandmalereien in Syrien. Qara und das Kloster Mar Yakub (SKCO 14; 2005).
  • B. Snelders, ‘A newly discovered wall painting in the Church of Mar Giworgis in Qaraqosh, Iraq’, ECA 4 (2007), 27–48.
  • S. Westphalen, ‘Wandmalereien in syrischen und libanesischen Kirchen. Aspekte christlicher Kunst im Orient vom 11.–13. Jahrhundert’, Antike Welt 31.5 (2000), 487–502.
  • M. Zibawi, Orients chrétiens (1996).